She is Sugar Free vs. MOONA: Collagen Cookie or Collagen Chocolate?
Anyone who wants collagen as a sweet snack rather than a powder quickly ends up with two very different products: the Collagen Cookies from She is Sugar Free and the collagen chocolate from MOONA. Both contain bovine collagen, but they take completely different approaches to sugar. This comparison looks at the Collagen Cookie (50 g) and MOONA Dark Chocolate 66 % with Collagen (70 g bar).
The Short Answer
If you want collagen without sugar, She is Sugar Free is clearly the better pick: the cookie contains 0.9 g of sugar per 100 g, the MOONA bar 20.8 g. It also offers more protein, fewer calories, and a price per 100 g of around one fifth. MOONA in turn scores with a declared collagen amount, a short ingredient list, and no sugar alcohols.
Why She is Sugar Free Comes Out Ahead
No added sugar instead of coconut blossom sugar
MOONA is sweetened with coconut blossom sugar; the dark bar contains 20.8 g of sugar per 100 g, the white version as much as 36.5 g. She is Sugar Free adds no sugar and comes to 0.9 g per 100 g, or 0.5 g per cookie. A whole MOONA bar contains around 14.6 g of sugar.
Around one fifth of the price
In the She is Sugar Free online shop, 100 g of cookies cost €3.30 to €3.48 depending on pack size. A 70 g MOONA bar costs €12.90 at its German retailer – €18.43 per 100 g.
More protein, fewer calories and saturated fat
Per 100 g, the cookie delivers 26 g of protein at 365 kcal and 6.9 g of saturated fat. The chocolate comes to 14.9 g of protein, 559 kcal, and 25.1 g of saturated fat.
A snack format for on the go
The cookies are individually wrapped and fit in any bag; a chocolate bar you portion yourself.
Where MOONA Scores
Collagen amount and branded ingredient declared
MOONA states that it contains 8 % hydrolysed bovine collagen from the branded ingredient VERISOL® – around 5.6 g per bar. She is Sugar Free does not state the collagen amount per cookie.
No sugar alcohols, short ingredient list
The dark bar consists of cocoa beans, coconut blossom sugar, cocoa butter, collagen, acerola, and acai. The cookie contains 10 g of maltitol per piece and therefore carries the warning that excessive consumption may have a laxative effect.
Gluten-free and with vitamin C
According to the manufacturer, MOONA is gluten-free, and thanks to acerola it contains 205 mg of vitamin C per 100 g. The cookie contains wheat flour and wheat protein.
Nutrition Side by Side
| Per 100 g | She is Sugar Free Collagen Cookie | MOONA Dark 66 % with Collagen |
|---|---|---|
| Energy | 365 kcal | 559 kcal |
| Fat / of which saturates | 13.5 g / 6.9 g | 41.7 g / 25.1 g |
| Carbohydrates | 40.0 g | 25.7 g |
| of which sugars | 0.9 g | 20.8 g |
| of which polyols | 20.0 g | none |
| Fibre | 5.8 g | not stated |
| Protein | 26.0 g | 14.9 g |
| Salt | 1.10 g | 0.04 g |
| Sweetening | Maltitol (no added sugar) | Coconut blossom sugar |
| Collagen | Bovine, amount not stated | Bovine, VERISOL®, 8 % |
| Gluten | Contains wheat | Gluten-free per manufacturer |
| Pack | 50 g cookies, individually wrapped | 70 g bar |
| Price per 100 g | €3.30–3.48 (online shop) | €18.43 (€12.90 per bar) |
Which One Is Right for You?
She is Sugar Free is the better choice if …
… you want to avoid sugar, are looking for a protein-rich sweet snack for every day, and don't want to spend more than €18 per 100 g.
MOONA is the better choice if …
… a precisely declared collagen dose from a branded ingredient matters to you, you don't tolerate sugar alcohols well or need to eat gluten-free, and sugar from coconut blossom is fine for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is MOONA sugar-free?
No. MOONA is sweetened with coconut blossom sugar and contains 20.8 g of sugar per 100 g (dark) or 36.5 g (white chocolate). If you are looking for collagen without added sugar, the Collagen Cookies from She is Sugar Free offer that.
Which product contains more collagen?
That can't be answered directly, because She is Sugar Free does not state its collagen amount. MOONA states 8 %, around 5.6 g per 70 g bar. The cookie contains 13 g of protein in total from collagen, wheat, and milk protein.
Which has fewer calories?
The cookie: 365 kcal per 100 g compared with 559 kcal for the chocolate. One cookie has 183 kcal, a whole MOONA bar around 390 kcal.
Where can I buy She is Sugar Free?
Through the online shop sheissugarfree.com and on Amazon. More about the brand in the She is Sugar Free brand profile. For an overview of collagen chocolate bars, see our guide to collagen chocolate.
Data Sources
Nutrition values, ingredients, and prices per manufacturer and retailer information, retrieved October 2026: She is Sugar Free Collagen Cookie, MOONA Dark Chocolate 66 % with Collagen, MOONA White Chocolate with Collagen, MOONA manufacturer. Prices may change.